Hard to value, but more than that! Insurance companies always offer low. Argue it by providing the insurance company examples of others for sale (if you can find any) and disputing about it's condition, rarity etc etc. I wouldn't even tell them how much you paid for it. It might take some time but you'll eventually get them up to a better price.
I'm sure a few people on here wouldn't mind sticking up a dummy ad on Pistonheads or something to aid your case.