Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Advantage & Disadvantage ?
405Mi16.com Forum > Technical Forums > Engine & Gearbox - Performance Upgrades
adrosy1
hey all , I need to know what happens when i put the gearbox of s16 on Mi16 motor , because i have a friend made that and when we raced together he but's the third gear & goes on and i can't catsh him , want to know if that's makes any damage, by the way my car is 205 with Mi16 & his car also 205 Mi16 with s16 gearbox .
WELSHPUG
it is the same gearbox.
snave
I have a question about his too.. My friend just put a Citroen Berlingo 1.9 diesel " gearbox on his mi16 engine, I had a ride with him -
1. he has better much torque and react like a short ratio gearbox
2. The gearbox is much lighter than the mi-16 gearbox


I think I will buy one too to fix on my Mi-16, has anyone ever tried here, just wanna knw if it is really worth it..
KRISKARRERA
Hi adrosy1, can you fill in your location on your profile please.

If a Citroen Berlingo 1.9 diesel gearbox has same or similar ratios to all the other psa diesel gearboxes they are best suited to things less peaky than an Mi16 engine.
Jer309GTi
The Berlingo/Partner box has very low and close gear ratios. It actually makes the thing accelerate not too bad at all for a van!

I wouldn't want one on an Mi however, you would just wheelspin and never get any traction IMO. And as for being lighter, they are basically the same box so don't know how that would work unsure.gif
KRISKARRERA
QUOTE (Jer309GTi @ Feb 14 2008, 06:32 PM)
The Berlingo/Partner box has very low and close gear ratios. It actually makes the thing accelerate not too bad at all for a van!
*
But why on a diesel?!
WELSHPUG
QUOTE (KRISKARRERA @ Feb 15 2008, 12:19 AM)
QUOTE (Jer309GTi @ Feb 14 2008, 06:32 PM)
The Berlingo/Partner box has very low and close gear ratios. It actually makes the thing accelerate not too bad at all for a van!
*
But why on a diesel?!
*



not meant for outright speed, weight shifting ability and circa 90 mph tops.

still handle damn well though, must be the 405 style rear beam arrangement wink.gif
KRISKARRERA
The inevitable next question is.... does anyone have info on the exact ratios?
snave
all that I knw is that My friend who has a berlingo gearbox has better take off the line than me, 1-2-3rd short shift and the 4th gear is long as my mi16 gearbox, he run up to 180km with the 4th gear and change to 5th.. It's really peaky yes .. and he dnt have wheelspin as he got 16"rims, that gearbox help him to compensate the loss he got with the big 16"rims on start, I think if with the 14" rims of Mi it wud have full wheelspin. iran on 17" and wondering I f I will put the gearbox, I already bought one yesterday itself, really light compared to the Mi gearbox.
Jer309GTi
QUOTE (WELSHPUG @ Feb 14 2008, 11:52 PM)
QUOTE (KRISKARRERA @ Feb 15 2008, 12:19 AM)
QUOTE (Jer309GTi @ Feb 14 2008, 06:32 PM)
The Berlingo/Partner box has very low and close gear ratios. It actually makes the thing accelerate not too bad at all for a van!
*
But why on a diesel?!
*



not meant for outright speed, weight shifting ability and circa 90 mph tops.

still handle damn well though, must be the 405 style rear beam arrangement wink.gif
*



*cough* 95 downhill on the governor blink.gif

And LOO and 4 wheel drifts are the order of the day biggrin.gif
KRISKARRERA
Hey Jer, over the weekend could you take the box off and count the teeth on all the gears please?
Jer309GTi
Hmm let me think.... No chance sorry! lol. I'll have a look in the handbook if I can find it, maybe it will list gear ratios in there? smile.gif
KRISKARRERA
Or has it got a rev counter?
WELSHPUG
don't be daft kriss laugh.gif the hdi version does though...
Jer309GTi
Yeah the HDi ones do. I've got a nice big clock instead in my dash! smile.gif
adrosy1
I still don't now which gearbox is most powerfull for the Mi16!!!!
Jer309GTi
What do you mean by 'the most powerful'? The one to give you the best acceleration, or the strongest box? Or something else? smile.gif
snave
QUOTE (KRISKARRERA @ Feb 15 2008, 03:19 AM)
QUOTE (Jer309GTi @ Feb 14 2008, 06:32 PM)
The Berlingo/Partner box has very low and close gear ratios. It actually makes the thing accelerate not too bad at all for a van!
*
But why on a diesel?!
*





Kris,
My opinion is that because diesel engine are slow at start that y they made short shift gearbox to give them torque.
snave
Guys, next week am going to fit the berlingo gearbox.. will let u knw the outcome
..
adrosy1
offcource best acceleration!!
Haze
the mi16 box is probably heavier because its a tougher box ie. more steel parts, bigger parts, etc.
snave
I finally put the diesel gearbox, the mi-16 run like a tiger !!!!!! grab the road with a nervosity as if am running on a 200 bhp tongue.gif

The gear ration is close and it has better acceleration ....
KRISKARRERA
Hehe you mean "run like a Lion"! Would love to know the exact ratios on that box. What speed are you doing at 3000rpm in 5th gear?
snave
QUOTE (KRISKARRERA @ Mar 6 2008, 08:42 PM)
Hehe you mean "run like a Lion"! Would love to know the exact ratios on that box. What speed are you doing at 3000rpm in 5th gear?
*


hehe u r right Kris.LION ..will check this weekend after my servicing done, Im putting castrol edge sport 10w 60 this time.
cybernck
^ i use that oil and my engines love it smile.gif.
adrosy1
I need to know the max. top speed?
snave
Sorry for late reply. I have to reply to Kris for " What speed are you doing at 3000rpm in 5th gear?
and adrosy1 for the top speed.
but unfortunately I cant give a proper answer because My fuel pump just let me down and I think it's not giving the full 3bar as stock. maybe 2 bar pressure. next weeke I 'll change the pump and put a new genuine Bosch 3 bar pump and come back to you with the statistic, but for sure, even with the pump disfunctionment I can feel a difference in accleration !
adrosy1
Go On
snave
QUOTE (KRISKARRERA @ Mar 6 2008, 08:42 PM)
Hehe you mean "run like a Lion"! Would love to know the exact ratios on that box. What speed are you doing at 3000rpm in 5th gear?
*


Here it is Kris, at 3000 rpm at 5th gear taking into factor am on 17"wheels it does 65mph. for the top speed.. gotta find an occasion for that coz it really scare me . lol


PS: see pics from mob attached
KRISKARRERA
Thanks dude. That 5th is longer than standard Mi16 box then. Are you guys left-hand drive out there?
snave
QUOTE (KRISKARRERA @ Mar 28 2008, 10:24 PM)
Thanks dude. That 5th is longer than standard Mi16 box then. Are you guys left-hand drive out there?
*



we are just like in Uk, right-hand drive. Am enjoying the gearbox to the max,my maximum speed till now is 225km/h on 5th gear and there was a lot to go but I pulled up my foot, was too much adrenaline for me.. smile.gif
petemi16
I can recomend using a Citroen VTS gearbox, very similar ratios to a mi box but with stronger internals
KRISKARRERA
I thought the VTS ratios were identical?
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2010 Invision Power Services, Inc.